Plans to establish a new takeaway food kiosk at Tenby Harbour have been halted after facing objections from the local council. The proposal, put forward by Ruby Goodrick to convert an old RNLI lifeboat store at Penniless Cove, Tenby Harbour into a cold food outlet, was denied despite an officer’s recommendation for approval. Goodrick, backed by a five-year lease from Pembrokeshire Council, had plans to operate the takeaway from 10am to 10pm, seven days a week.
Although the officer’s report suggested that the introduction of a retail element at the harbour would not significantly harm the area’s character, concerns were raised during a meeting of the development management committee of the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park. Alistair Mckay, representing Tenby Sailing Club, expressed apprehensions about potential conflicts arising from the new establishment impacting other harbour users. This led to a motion for refusal by Councillor Simon Hancock, who felt that the proposed site was not suitable for such a venture.
Goodrick, keen on reviving the vacant building with her vision for Truly@The Harbour, aimed to create a positive economic impact while honouring her mother’s business legacy in town. Despite her willingness to make adjustments to address concerns such as congestion and waste management, committee members leaned towards rejecting the application. Councillor Hancock, echoing sentiments about preserving the historical integrity of the harbour, highlighted the importance of not setting a precedent for unsuitable commercial ventures in the area.
The decision to block the takeaway plans was supported by Tenby councillor Councillor Sam Skyrme-Blackhall, who stressed the significance of upholding the unique historic value of Tenby Harbour. The committee’s vote, with 12 members favouring refusal and three against, signalled a firm stance against commercialization that could potentially compromise the area’s heritage. Additionally, a related application for a display board advertising the takeaway was deferred for further review before a final decision was made.
The proposal had also faced criticism from Tenby Civic Society and Tenby North county councillor Michael Williams, who voiced concerns over the possible negative impact on the historical environment of the Grade-II-listed harbour estate. Councillor Williams highlighted the existing use of the harbour by commercial fishing vessels and stressed the incompatibility of the proposed takeaway with such activities. He cautioned against allowing developments that could pave the way for unacceptable commercial exploitation in the area.
The rejection of the plans underscores the significance of balancing economic opportunities with preserving the cultural and historical heritage of iconic locations like Tenby Harbour. As stakeholders continue to navigate the delicate balance between development and conservation, the decision serves as a reminder of the importance of thoughtful planning to protect cherished landmarks for future generations. Goodrick’s vision for Truly@The Harbour may need to undergo substantial revisions or find a more suitable location to align with the local community’s concerns and priorities.