A Vale of Glamorgan councillor has come under scrutiny after emails discussing controversial plans to use a former school site for emergency accommodation in Llantwit Major were published. The site, formerly occupied by Eagleswell Primary School, was initially approved for 90 temporary modular homes through permitted development rights, bypassing the need for traditional planning permission. An email trail obtained by campaigners revealed that Councillor Gwyn John chose not to inform residents about the plans, stating in a November 2022 email that “before long someone will work out what is going on.”
Residents living near the modular homes raised concerns about the lack of consultation regarding the design of the site, particularly its proximity to existing properties. It was later revealed that the site would remain in place for a minimum of five years, following approval by Vale of Glamorgan Council’s planning committee in July 2024. Legal action against the council was considered by campaigners dissatisfied with the handling of the scheme.
Parking issues at the site were also brought to light through an email exchange among senior planners. Concerns were raised about the adequacy of the proposed 20 car parking spaces for 90 units over the intended five-year period. Discussions led to a revised plan of one car parking space per two units, along with additional spaces for visitors. The council defended the decision, citing its responsibility to resettle Ukrainian refugees as a primary consideration in accommodating those in need.
While the controversy surrounding the Eagleswell development continues, the council maintains that extensive communication efforts were made with residents once details of the scheme were finalised. The balancing act between addressing urgent housing needs and community concerns remains a central issue in the ongoing saga. Residents and stakeholders await further updates as the development progresses.