A recent report has revealed shocking cases of systematic sexual abuse of children on Caldey Island, off the coast of Pembrokeshire. The victims, many of whom were orphans and vulnerable, were lured to the island where they endured horrific abuse. Victims have come forward with their traumatic experiences, with one survivor collecting 59 victim accounts so far. This has prompted calls for a public inquiry, as it is believed that the abuse may have occurred on an “industrial scale” on the island.
A safeguarding review conducted by consultant social worker Jan Pickles concluded that victims of sexual abuse on Caldey Island were mistreated in a hostile and heartless manner. The report highlighted the suffering caused to the children who were promised a holy and enjoyable experience but were instead left with lasting mental scars. The report also shed light on the actions of Father Thaddeus Kotik, known as “Father Thadd” to victims, who was described as a serial and prolific abuser of children on the island.
Victims recounted horrifying experiences of being taken to secluded places by Kotik for repeated abuse. Some victims reported being assaulted multiple times a day during the summer months. Shockingly, witnesses have come forward describing how Kotik’s predatory behaviour was openly tolerated by adults on the island, indicating a systemic failure to protect the children. Despite allegations being made to the abbey leadership, no action was taken to address the abuse or involve the authorities.
The review also revealed that several convicted offenders with a history of sexual offences had resided on Caldey Island at different times. This disturbing pattern of abuse involving multiple perpetrators has cast a dark shadow over the island’s reputation. The failure to safeguard vulnerable children and address allegations of abuse has raised serious concerns about the leadership and accountability within the abbey.
Kevin O’Connell, a survivor of abuse on Caldey Island, has been advocating for justice for the victims through the Caldey Island Survivors Campaign. His efforts have brought attention to the widespread abuse and the need for a thorough investigation into the extent of the atrocities committed on the island. The survivors, through their courage in sharing their experiences, have highlighted the urgent need for accountability and a commitment to preventing such abuse from ever happening again.
In response to the report, Father Jan Rossey, the abbey’s current abbot, expressed deep regret and apologised for the past failures to protect children from abuse. He acknowledged the need for improved safeguarding measures and vowed to ensure a proper response to any allegations of abuse in the future. The call for a public inquiry by lawyer Michael Imperato underscores the gravity of the situation and the importance of uncovering the truth about the extent of the abuse on Caldey Island.
The survivors, supported by advocates like Dinah Mulholland, are determined to seek justice and closure for the horrors they endured. The impact of the abuse has had far-reaching consequences, with victims like Mr O’Connell’s sister tragically losing her life due to the trauma she experienced. The survivors’ resilience and determination to hold those responsible to account reflect a relentless pursuit of justice and a commitment to ensuring the safety and well-being of vulnerable children in the future.
As the investigation into the historic child abuse allegations on Caldey Island unfolds, the survivors’ voices grow louder, demanding recognition, validation, and accountability for the crimes committed against them. The revelations of widespread abuse and the failure to protect children on the island serve as a stark reminder of the urgent need to address systemic failures in safeguarding and to ensure that the voices of survivors are heard and respected.