The seaside town of Barmouth in Gwynedd is currently experiencing a divide among its residents regarding a proposed solution to a pressing issue. Despite being a popular destination for visitors from the West Midlands, the town has faced challenges, especially concerning housing affordability for locals. Traders in Barmouth have reported a successful tourism season, even after encountering unpredictable weather conditions in recent summers.
Stephen Charles Staff, a donkey ride trader with 38 years of experience in the town, mentioned that Barmouth has remained busy, attracting both visitors and retired individuals. The reliance on tourism in Barmouth, which was recently recognised by the Sunday Times as one of the best places to live by the sea, has led to significant economic contributions to Gwynedd. However, the surge in second homes has caused housing affordability issues, prompting the introduction of new legislation requiring planning permission for second homes.
Despite the intentions behind the article four directive to address the housing crisis exacerbated by second homes, there are concerns that it could negatively impact the housing market and hinder opportunities for locals to purchase properties. The average house price in Gwynedd remains high compared to the average salary, creating challenges for many residents, including Stephen’s sons who are struggling to afford property in the county.
Aleksandra Przybysz, a local business owner at Bermo Bistro, highlighted the need for a balance between tourism and local housing affordability. The discussion around second homes has sparked a debate within the county, with campaign groups both supporting and criticising the proposed legislation. While some residents believe the measures are necessary to protect the housing market and foster community cohesion, others raise concerns about their potential impact on tourism and property values.
The issue extends beyond Barmouth to other areas in Gwynedd, such as Abersoch, where the prevalence of second homes has influenced housing availability and affordability. Rhys Elvins, an estate agent, expressed concerns about the restrictions that the new legislation could impose on property sales and the potential consequences for residents looking to sell their homes.
As Gwynedd grapples with the complexities of balancing tourism, housing affordability, and community cohesion, the debate over second homes continues to divide opinions among locals. While the council aims to address the housing crisis through innovative measures, the long-term implications of the proposed legislation remain uncertain as residents navigate the challenges of property ownership, tourism, and community sustainability in the county.